Most guidance on grant proposals tells you to write for your audience. Reasonable advice, but incomplete. Understanding your panel is a strategic exercise: a disciplined attempt to see your proposal through the eyes of the people holding the decision, and to position your work in relation to what they are genuinely trying to achieve.
What is this funder actually trying to do?
Every funding call exists because a funder has a strategic priority: advancing a field, closing a knowledge gap, or signalling direction to a research community. Your proposal lands better if you can explicitly name that priority. Read the call documentation carefully, but look beyond it too. What else has this funder supported recently? What debates in your field are they trying to influence? Those answers will tell you what to foreground and what to address before reviewers raise it.
The panel’s unspoken questions
Each review panel carries concerns that do not appear in the criteria. They are asking: is this team realistic? Have they thought about what could go wrong? Is this genuinely new, or familiar work in new packaging? Strong proposals anticipate those questions and answer them without being asked. Stand outside your own expertise for a moment. What would a sceptical, well-informed reviewer push back on? Address it directly.
Positioning is a choice, not a given
How you position your work relative to what already exists is one of the most consequential decisions in your proposal. Too close to existing work, and reviewers question the novelty. Too distant, and they question the feasibility. The right position names the gap, explains why it exists, and shows why your approach is the one that can close it. That positioning comes from honest analysis, not from writing.
The critical friend test
Find someone in your field who is not on your team. Ask them to read your proposal with one question in mind: what would a sceptical reviewer push back on? Resistance or hesitation is not a problem to defend against. It is information about how your proposal is landing, and it is far better to receive it before submission than after.
Image by vectorjuice on Freepik
Recent Comments